EW's Underrated/Overrated

[flkofcguls]

EW did a Top 5 of the most Underrated Performers in AI History and Most
Overrated, as well. Here's how they played out.

Top Five Most Underrated:

1- Jennifer Hudson
2- Lisa Leuschner
3- Trenyce
4- George Huff
5- Jessica Sierra


Top Five Most Overrated:

1- Carrie Underwood
2- Diana DeGarmo
3- Constantine Maroulis
4- Justin Guarini
5- Vonzell Solomon

[Elton Dumont]

Post by flkofcguls
EW did a Top 5 of the most Underrated Performers in AI History and Most
Overrated, as well. Here's how they played out.
1- Jennifer Hudson
2- Lisa Leuschner
3- Trenyce
4- George Huff
5- Jessica Sierra
1- Carrie Underwood
2- Diana DeGarmo
3- Constantine Maroulis
4- Justin Guarini
5- Vonzell Solomon

Its a very subjective list...however, I do agree with Lisa, Jessica, Carrie,
Constantine and especially Justin.

Elton

[Tzigaane]

Post by flkofcguls
EW did a Top 5 of the most Underrated Performers in AI History and Most
Overrated, as well. Here's how they played out.
1- Jennifer Hudson
2- Lisa Leuschner
3- Trenyce
4- George Huff
5- Jessica Sierra

Jennifer and Jessica were two of my favorites and I'm really really
sorry we never got to hear Lisa Leuschner in the top 12. I don't think
Trenyce or George were underrated though. They both went out higher
than I though they should have

Post by flkofcguls
1- Carrie Underwood
2- Diana DeGarmo
3- Constantine Maroulis
4- Justin Guarini
5- Vonzell Solomon

THe only one of these I'd say was overrated was Vonzell, she of the
constant pitch problems. Constantine wasn't always consistent, but then
he did go out earlier than many expected so I wouldn't say he was overrated.

tzigaane

[Dale Bowman]

Underrated......Scott Savol

[flkofcguls]

Post by Dale Bowman
Underrated......Scott Savol

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.

Wait... you were serious?

[fmomoon]

Post by Dale Bowman
Underrated......Scott Savol

Nice voice, but lousy stage presence. There is a certain "Ick" quality to
him.

[Buz Murdock]

OVER & UNDER - WHATEVER!!!
TWO SUPER TALENTS WERE OVERLOOKED VONZEL & MICHELAH!!
spelling wrong, Sorry about that!
michalah, michelah, mikalah , michelah
NO MATTER HOW YOU SPELL IT!!
SHE IS AWESOME!!!!
Carrie was a mistake!!!
I used to like Bo
but his album sucks!!
SO........
These 2 should have WON!!!!!!

[The Chris]

Post by flkofcguls
EW did a Top 5 of the most Underrated Performers in AI History and Most
Overrated, as well. Here's how they played out.
1- Jennifer Hudson
2- Lisa Leuschner
3- Trenyce
4- George Huff
5- Jessica Sierra
1- Carrie Underwood
2- Diana DeGarmo
3- Constantine Maroulis
4- Justin Guarini
5- Vonzell Solomon

Is Guarini really overrated?? Is he rated??:)

[Pidge]

Post by The Chris

Post by flkofcguls
EW did a Top 5 of the most Underrated Performers in AI History and Most
Overrated, as well. Here's how they played out.
1- Jennifer Hudson
2- Lisa Leuschner
3- Trenyce
4- George Huff
5- Jessica Sierra
1- Carrie Underwood
2- Diana DeGarmo
3- Constantine Maroulis
4- Justin Guarini
5- Vonzell Solomon

Is Guarini really overrated?? Is he rated??:)

Poor Diana is NOT overrated. Idiot EW.

-------------
To send email, replace "antispam" with "sympatico"

[fmomoon]

Post by flkofcguls
EW did a Top 5 of the most Underrated Performers in AI History and Most
Overrated, as well. Here's how they played out.
1- Jennifer Hudson
2- Lisa Leuschner
3- Trenyce
4- George Huff
5- Jessica Sierra

Agree on #1. That's pretty much it.

Post by flkofcguls
1- Carrie Underwood
2- Diana DeGarmo
3- Constantine Maroulis
4- Justin Guarini
5- Vonzell Solomon

Well, 4 out of 5 I agree with. :)

[Bob Rudd]

Post by fmomoon

Post by flkofcguls
EW did a Top 5 of the most Underrated Performers in AI History and Most
Overrated, as well. Here's how they played out.
1- Jennifer Hudson
2- Lisa Leuschner
3- Trenyce
4- George Huff
5- Jessica Sierra

I would agree on Jessica, not the others.

Post by fmomoon
Agree on #1. That's pretty much it.

Post by flkofcguls
1- Carrie Underwood
2- Diana DeGarmo
3- Constantine Maroulis
4- Justin Guarini
5- Vonzell Solomon

Well, 4 out of 5 I agree with. :)

Guarini and Solomon, yes. Constantine, maybe. Diana and Carrie,
definitely not.

[Mark Stringer]

Post by flkofcguls
1- Jennifer Hudson
2- Lisa Leuschner
3- Trenyce
4- George Huff
5- Jessica Sierra

Huff was my fav in season 3 but he had at least three weeks in a
row where he made poor song choices before he finally got the boot.
You end up asking yourself if he ever really did sing well and you
begin to wonder why you liked him in the first place. Not the
memory you want to leave people with. Song choice can make or break
you. Also, didn't George do the Bobo?

[Bob Rudd]

In article <***@vtn1.victoria.tc.ca>, ui337
@victoria.tc.ca says...

Post by Mark Stringer
Also, didn't George do the Bobo?

More the 360.

[soon to choose]

What's "bobo"? I keep seeing this but have no idea what it means? Tks.

[Ezelle F]

(soon=A0to=A0choose)
What's "bobo"? I keep seeing this but have
no idea what it means? Tks.

http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=3Dbo+bo

5. bo bo
The name of the dance performed by American Idol winner Fantasia
Barrino.
a dance that combines intricate dance steps and leg movements.

7. bo bo
Fantasia Barrino's victory dance on 'American Idol.'
Fantasia did the bo bo when she won!

Loading Image...

[Suzanne D.]

"Ezelle F" <***@webtv.net> wrote in message news:2305-4415A88A-***@storefull-

http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=bo+bo

5. bo bo
The name of the dance performed by American Idol winner Fantasia
Barrino.
a dance that combines intricate dance steps and leg movements.


I wouldn't really characterize it as combining "intricate dance steps and
leg movements." It was more like "Leaning to one side and gently hopping."
No dance or leg movements involved.
--S.

[Itoshi]

Post by Suzanne D.
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=bo+bo
5. bo bo
The name of the dance performed by American Idol winner Fantasia
Barrino.
a dance that combines intricate dance steps and leg movements.
I wouldn't really characterize it as combining "intricate dance steps and
leg movements." It was more like "Leaning to one side and gently hopping."
No dance or leg movements involved.

For Fantasia, that was intricate.

[Elton Dumont]

Post by Itoshi

Post by Suzanne D.
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=bo+bo
5. bo bo
The name of the dance performed by American Idol winner Fantasia
Barrino.
a dance that combines intricate dance steps and leg movements.
I wouldn't really characterize it as combining "intricate dance steps and
leg movements." It was more like "Leaning to one side and gently hopping."
No dance or leg movements involved.

For Fantasia, that was intricate.

I never ever do this...but ....lmao....


Elton

[Karrde]

Post by Itoshi

Post by Suzanne D.
I wouldn't really characterize it as combining "intricate dance steps and
leg movements." It was more like "Leaning to one side and gently hopping."
No dance or leg movements involved.

For Fantasia, that was intricate.

I thought she was just trying to shake out another baby.

--K

[Itoshi]

On 13 Mar 2006 08:14:48 -0800, "soon to choose"

Post by soon to choose
What's "bobo"? I keep seeing this but have no idea what it means? Tks.

It's Fantasia's signature dance. It's not much different from jogging in
place, except you don't wear shoes or a bra when doing it.

[Mark Stringer]

Post by Itoshi

Post by soon to choose
What's "bobo"? I keep seeing this but have no idea what it means?
Tks.

It's Fantasia's signature dance. It's not much different from
jogging in place, except you don't wear shoes or a bra when doing
it.

I thought it was the squat move but now I remember it. It was bad
but it was a good bad.

[Ezelle F]

Ryan Seacrest learned it on the May 3, Final Five Special

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v314/EzelleF/Tasia1/ryans_bobo.gif

..sort of

[Sanna]

Post by Ezelle F
Ryan Seacrest learned it on the May 3, Final Five Special
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v314/EzelleF/Tasia1/ryans_bobo.gif
..sort of

LMAO. I'm sorry but that is so fked up.

[Bernie]

Jennifer Hudson?? She belongs in the overrated column..All she did was yell
songs with bludgeoning power to the point your ears would bleed

Post by flkofcguls
EW did a Top 5 of the most Underrated Performers in AI History and Most
Overrated, as well. Here's how they played out.
1- Jennifer Hudson
2- Lisa Leuschner
3- Trenyce
4- George Huff
5- Jessica Sierra
1- Carrie Underwood
2- Diana DeGarmo
3- Constantine Maroulis
4- Justin Guarini
5- Vonzell Solomon

[c***@yahoo.com]

Post by Bernie
Jennifer Hudson?? She belongs in the overrated column..All she did was yell
songs with bludgeoning power to the point your ears would bleed

Some people still believe that a booming voice equals talent. That's
why you see a bunch of these morons yell out their song. Hudson is a
one-trick pony. Any song you hand to her, she'll only sing it one way
- she'll belt it out. She has no control. Remember when she sang the
Manilow song? That was hilarous. How can anyone yell out the song
Weekend in New England?

[Mickey]

Post by c***@yahoo.com

Post by Bernie
Jennifer Hudson?? She belongs in the overrated column..All she did was yell
songs with bludgeoning power to the point your ears would bleed

Some people still believe that a booming voice equals talent. That's
why you see a bunch of these morons yell out their song. Hudson is a
one-trick pony. Any song you hand to her, she'll only sing it one way
- she'll belt it out. She has no control. Remember when she sang the
Manilow song? That was hilarous. How can anyone yell out the song
Weekend in New England?

Wagnerian soprano, Margaret Harshaw, is sometimes credited with saying
that "if you want to find great big beautiful voices, go to a truck
stop." Big voices are common, artists aren't. When in comes to
performing, it's still brain more than brawn.

The Other Mickey

[Texas Guy 3]

Well, you may think that Jennifer Hudson belongs in the overrated
category, but apparently Hollywood doesn't agree with you. She beat out
Fantasia for the roll of "Effie" in "Dreamgirls", so we will see how
well she does in December. I really enjoyed her on AI.

[Ezelle F]

Post by Texas Guy 3
Well, you may think that Jennifer Hudson
belongs in the overrated category, but
apparently Hollywood doesn't agree with you.
She beat out Fantasia for the roll of "Effie" in
"Dreamgirls", so we will see how well she
does in December. I really enjoyed her on AI.

Well, in this case Hollywood =3D David Geffen & Bill Condon.

[Texas Guy 3]

Sorry, guess I should have clarified that....LOL!!!!

[Dale Bowman]

Jennifer Hudson..... a natural actress, she was actually playing a role
on AI as a singer, but didn't realize it.

[c***@yahoo.com]

Post by Dale Bowman
Jennifer Hudson..... a natural actress, she was actually playing a role
on AI as a singer, but didn't realize it.

Hudson is indeed over-rated but if you put her in the right role, she
sounds really good. When she sang Circle of Life, pairing the style of
music to her style of singing, then she looks very good at it. On the
other hand, when you pair her up with a song that requires the singer
to actually sing softly with a mellow touch, that's when Hudson sounds
really bad. That's why I call her a one-trick pony but it doesn't mean
she won't have a great career ahead of her.

[karenftx]

Post by flkofcguls
EW did a Top 5 of the most Underrated Performers in AI History and Most
Overrated, as well. Here's how they played out.
1- Jennifer Hudson
2- Lisa Leuschner
3- Trenyce
4- George Huff
5- Jessica Sierra
1- Carrie Underwood
2- Diana DeGarmo
3- Constantine Maroulis
4- Justin Guarini
5- Vonzell Solomon

Take out Diana and Constantine and put in Tamyra or LaToya and I will agree
with it all.